Lent 3 B: Igniting Centrifugal Force
Dear Partner in Preaching,
Any careful reader of John’s Gospel will notice that his account varies from his synoptic cousins at a variety of points, few more significant than in today’s reading. Rather than place Jesus’ cleansing of the Temple at the end of Jesus’ public ministry, as Matthew, Mark, and Luke do, John places it here at the beginning of the story.
Why? Because of distinct theological agendas. Keep in mind that the Gospels are confessions of faith from the first century rather than historical accounts of the twenty-first century. So each difference provides us with a clue to the distinct confession of faith the particular evangelist offers. In this case, the synoptic writers cast the disruption in the Temple as the final provocative act of Jesus that precipitates his arrest, trial, and crucifixion. John, however, uses this same scene to announce the inauguration of a new era, one in which the grace of God is no longer mediated or accessed through cultic sacrifice but instead is available to all who receive Jesus as God’s Messiah.
Notice, for instance, that not only the timing of Jesus’ actions is different in John, but so is the accusation he levels at the moneychangers. Rather than accuse them of turning the Temple into a “den of robbers” – accusing them, that is, of defrauding the poor – Jesus instead says they have turned the Temple into a market place. Ironically, however, the Temple had to be a market place – or at least have a market place – so as to enable devout Jews to purchase animals for sacrifice and to change the Imperial coin for the local currency with which to make such purchases. So when Jesus drives the animals out of the Temple, overturns the tables of the moneychangers, and demands the end of buying and selling, he is really announcing the end of this way of relating to God.
God is no longer available primarily, let alone exclusively, via the Temple. Instead, as John confesses in the opening verses of his account, Jesus invites us to experience God’s grace upon grace (1:17) through our faith in him. Given that John’s account was written well after the destruction of the Jerusalem Temple by the Romans, his insistence – and perhaps reassurance – to his community that they would find God’s mercy in Christ outside rather than inside the Temple makes practical as well as theological sense. And, to tell you the truth, I think it has the same potential today.
Many of our people, I suspect, tend to think of church as a destination. It’s a place you go to receive…well, spiritual things (actually, it’d be interesting to ask people what they expect to receive at church, but that’s probably another sermon!). But, taking a cue from John, I wonder if we’ve got things a little backwards. Don’t get me wrong, I think worship is important. But rather than imagine it’s a place we go to for some experience of God, I wonder if we shouldn’t imagine it as a place we’re sent from in order to meet, and partner with, God in everyday life.
C. S. Lewis’ third book of his Narnia series, The Voyage of the ‘Dawn Treader’, provides a wonderful illustration of what I’m talking about. If you remember, in The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe, the four Penvensie children travel from war-torn London to Narnia and there meet the great lion (and Christ-figure), Aslan, and with his help defeat the White Witch who holds Narnia captive in a perpetual winter. In the second book, the children travel back to assist Prince Caspian in obtaining his rightful throne, and at the end of that book Aslan tells the two older children, Peter and Susan, that they will not return to Narnia.
Now, at the end of the third book, Aslan meets Lucy and Edmund at the edge of the Eastern Sea and tells them the same, that this will be their last trip to Narnia. Lucy is distraught at the prospect of not seeing the beloved lion again, but he reassures her that she will see him in her own world. When she is surprised that Aslan is present in her world, he tells her that the whole reason for bringing her to Narnia for a time was so that, coming to know him well here, she would recognize him more easily there.
Isn’t that a great image for church? We come to church because in the proclamation of the Gospel and sharing of the sacraments we perceive God’s grace most clearly. But then we are sent out to look for God and, even more, to partner with God in our various roles and venues to love and bless the people and world God loves so much.
But I’m not sure how many of our people see church that way. Or, more accurately, I’m not sure they see their homes, places of work, school, and other parts of their lives as places where God is present, let alone at work through them for the sake of the world. And I think we may have unintentionally contributed to this confusion. Let me explain.
David Miller, at the beginning of his book, God at Work, describes an exercise he often does with groups of clergy. How many of you, Miller typically asks, at the beginning of a new program and school year recognize Sunday School teachers, inviting them to stand, “installing” them, and/or praying for them? All the hands in the room go up. And how many of you, he continues, after your annual meeting and election of new church council (or Board of Elders or Vestry) members, recognize them during worship, “installing” or “consecrating” them and/or praying for them. Again, almost all the hands go up. What about our youth? Miller goes on. When your youth group goes on a mission trip, how many of you commission them before they go or pray for them while they are away? By this time, of course, the response is predictable, as most of the hands are raised. One more question, Miller then says. How many of you, come late March or early April, invite all of our Certified Public Accountants to stand and pray for them, knowing that for the next several weeks they will work seventy hours or more and that their labor keeps our tax system and government functioning? And now there are almost no hands raised in the air.
Do you see what I mean? By regularly emphasizing the roles we play at church, we unintentionally undervalue all the other roles of our lives and lift up church as the one place where we meet God and live our religious lives and in this way, I think, undermine John’s insight and confession that God is out in the world waiting for us to partner with God.
Allow one more way to get at this. When I was in junior high school, I remember learning about the difference between centripetal and centrifugal force. Centripetal force is what pulls objects toward the middle, where as centrifugal force sends things to the outside (it’s that force that keeps you, for instance, plastered to the wall of the spinning amusement park ride so you don’t fall when it tilts one way or another). I think our congregational life, Dear Partner, is dominated by centripetal force and I’d like us to work to change it to centrifugal, so that while people do indeed come to church to experience God, that experience and the clearer picture they gain of God from it, end up sending our people back out into the world to serve God by serving neighbor in the various vocational arenas of their life.
And you could help move us to such centrifugal force in at least two easy ways this week. First, after opening up John’s confession, you could begin lifting up one vocational arena in the prayers and commit to doing that each and every week. (If you do so, keep in mind that vocation includes, but also goes beyond, occupation to include school, home, and places of volunteering and recreation.)
A second suggestion for igniting the power of centrifugal force would be to pass out 3×5 cards and have each person write out one place they know they will be this week and then collect those cards with the offering. During the prayers, you could then pray that when we are in those ordinary places this week we will look for, see, and partner with the God we have heard about in John’s Gospel reading and our worship this morning. It’s one small step, I know, but if even a few people leave church looking for God in their everyday lives I think it would be totally worth it.
Thanks so much, Dear Partner, for joining me – and John! – in helping people see God’s grace present and manifest to them in their daily lives and in this way more fully claim their baptismal identity as disciples of Jesus. Your preaching makes a difference in helping them be the people God has called them to be.
Yours in Christ,
David
PS: In the fourth chapter of Preaching at the Crossroads, I offer a number of other suggestions for helping transform church from a “God-box” to a “vocational counseling center.”
Thank you so much for your deep insights I really amazed by your 3x 5 cards idea. I am going to try it Sunday. May God continue to inspire you day by day. Thanks again! May God bless you and your ministry.
May God continue to inspire you day by day. Thanks again! May God bless you and your ministry.
May God bless you and your ministry.
As someone who went to the SAME Reynolds Jr. High School as you did, albeit a few years earlier, maybe we both learned something there. I don’t know. However, in our church we did exactly as you described handing out cards for several weeks and asking people where they would be on Monday morning or any time during the week. We then gathered them, and I took them and put these things into prayers that we used during the SENDING for about four weeks. It was wonderful. Thanks. John Trump
It was Wheatland Jr. High for me, John, but I assume it was the healthy Lancaster air that infected us both. 🙂
Great to hear from you.
Perhaps a satirical way to look at the centripetal verses centrifugal force: Centrifugal force sends to the outer edges; centripetal sends us down the drain. Oh, maybe that’s metaphorical, not satirical. 😉
I am compelled to disagree. Worship is not centrifugal it must be centripetal, unless you would rob the sacraments and God’s word of their very power to gather and send. The very heart of what goes on in worship (God’s acting on us) is what makes all the rest of the week possible. It is not the rest of the week that gives worship meaning. That would be as if our works were somehow more important than God’s works. Instead, It is worship that gives the rest of the week meaning! Worship is where God shows up because God promises to show up! We could look endlessly in those places in our daily lives, and never find God as surely as God shows up in the bath, word, and table. I do not mean that God is not present out there in our daily lives, but rather, it is worship that shows us this not our daily lives. Christ gives our vocations all meaning and worth, for without Christ we can accomplish nothing. So it is that worship makes more of us, not the other way around (We do not make more of worship out in the world.) We could not help our neighbor nor be sent out into the world, without first being freed ourselves through the Gospel which happens to us every time we gather in worship. There is no sending apart from a strong center of Christ. There is no service apart from the service that Christ works in us in worship. I do not have to argue this alone, Timothy Wengert edited a book with the very title Centripetal Worship, where along with Mark Mummert, Melinda Quivick, and Dirk G. Lange all of them argue this point more eloquently than I can.
Further, the scripture itself puts the new center of worship not in the temple nor out in the world and every day life: but in Christ which makes the world and every day life possible.
This is very helpful, Thomas. You’ve pointed out well, I think, the shortcomings of only thinking about our life centrifugally, as absent connect to worship, the community, and the sacraments, it can become shallow and give the impression that it’s all up to us. But of course centrifugal force pushes you out from a center, and that center is, in fact, worship, the community, and the sacraments. I just can’t imagine that what God wants most is for us to be drawn to church for worship. I think worship serves to equip us to go out into the world God cares for so much. Perhaps either term – centrifugal or centripetal – can feel a little incomplete. Maybe the image of a flywheel is better, as we are drawn into worship in order to be turned around and sent back out again. Or, as I often say, perhaps we might say that the movement in toward church and worship and out again to service in the world is the respiratory system of the Body of Christ. Breathed in to be renewed in faith, breathed out to be sent in service. Thanks for joining in the conversation.
There is yet another perspective; liturgy as the work of the people. We create a drama to remind us of who and whose we are, to rebuild our context in the light of God’s grace and call. There is no ‘worshipbook’ of instructions in the biblical text. We acknowledge the sacraments (some of us – Quakers are a little different here) as ‘means of grace’ but not under our control. Worship may be the place God meets us, or it may be where folk cry ‘Lord, Lord,’ and are focused on their ability to perform. We don’t control the Spirit, but we do remember and acknowledge the Spirit’s presence in our lives as 24/7 realities.
Thank you, David. Over the years your insights and perspective have inspired me and by extension many in the church. May God continue to bless your ministry.
Thank you for your kind response. I think you are right. Either way, we have to break the metaphor. The center of Christ is a strange kind of center, that opens us up and pulls us out toward the boundaries. The boundaries are indeed a place that we are pushed out toward, but the importance of being drawn in then can often be overlooked. As with all things, the rule is complexity and paradox win the day not simplicity or clarity. No metaphor is a clean one. That is why I like your suggestion of a respiratory system, because as an organic system it includes all manner of different motions and functions (as opposed to a simple force doing one motion or another). It also points me back to incarnation, and the bodied-ness of both Christ and the Church. It is a metaphor that in itself invites complexity. Whereas our previous metaphors of centrifugal/centripetal, the complexity must be explained into them.