Matthew 27:11-14

Posted by DJL on Apr 2, 2014 in Lenten Devotions | 1 comment

Now Jesus stood before the governor; and the governor asked him, “Are you the King of the Jews?” Jesus said, “You say so.” But when he was accused by the chief priests and elders, he did not answer. Then Pilate said to him, “Do you not hear how many accusations they make against you?” But he gave him no answer, not even to a single charge, so that the governor was greatly amazed.

After the narrative detour regarding Judas’ tragic end, we are back to the primary story of Jesus’ journey to the cross. He is now before Pilate, arguably the most powerful man in all of Palestine, for trial.

Pilate begins with what may seem a straightforward question, but one that has far reaching implications: “Are you the King of the Jews?” Jesus’ answer will help Pilate discern whether this is primarily a religious squabble or one that has more political overtones. But Jesus refuses to satisfy Pilate’s curiosity, employing the same strategy he had earlier: “You say so.” At this non-answer, his accusers jump into the fray, but as before Jesus refuses to answer any of them. Pilate, then, prods him further, inviting him to address the charges spoken against him. And Jesus remains silent.

All of this may not seem that surprising, as Jesus has retained his rather stoic sense of self and mission ever since his anguish and resolve in Gethsemane. What strikes me, though, is that Pilate is “amazed.” Why?

Perhaps because most of those who have been brought before Pilate came as terrified and beaten opponents of the empire, yet this man is unafraid. Or perhaps those Pilate usually speaks to are out for their own political gain, always seeking an advantage, and yet this one seems to desire no favor. Or maybe it’s that the normal human reaction when accused of something is to defend oneself vigorously and level counter-charges at one’s opponents, and yet this rabbi speaks not a word either in his defense or against his accusers.

Pilate, based on his experience with power and influence and violence, has a whole set of expectations about how Jesus should respond. Yet Jesus, acquainted instead with grace, faith, and trust, defies those expectations, remains silent in the face of his accusers, and entrusts himself to the mercy of God.

Yes, Pilate is amazed. For Jesus abides by the rules of another kingdom altogether, one Pilate cannot image but only wonder at.

Prayer: Dear God, remind us daily that while we live and work in this world, we are also citizens of your eternal kingdom. In Jesus’ name, Amen.