Pentecost 4 A: Understood, Accepted, and Loved
Introductory Note: A week ago I was informed by email that Luther Seminary has determined that the column I started five years ago, Dear Working Preacher, can only be written by a member of Luther’s faculty and so I was asked to draw my involvement to a close. I did that last week. Over the course of the years I wrote my weekly letter, connecting with preachers and inviting them to share in the road of experimentation and discovery I have been on has become a central part of my own vocation as a preacher and teacher. And so I will continue writing these weekly letters of encouragement and post them here. I hope they are helpful. While I toyed with a variety of names, I wanted to preserve the sense that this column is still just a letter from one preacher to others and so will call it simply, “Dear Partner in Preaching.”
Pentecost 4 A: Matthew 11:16-19, 25-30 ~ Understood, Accepted, and Loved
Dear Partner in Preaching,
Call it “Lose’s Law”: To be…is to be misunderstood. Do you know what I mean? Our life in this world is marked by a profound desire to be understood, to be known, to be accepted, and yet so much of life is colored by being misunderstood and feeling like we are neither known nor accepted for whom we really are.
To be is to be misunderstood. Whatever we call it, I suspect Jesus would have agreed. At the beginning of this chapter, the imprisoned John the Baptist sent his disciples to ask Jesus whether he was the one foretold by prophecy or whether they should look for another. Jesus responded by naming his “deeds of power” – not of conquest but of healing – and then went on to instruct the crowds about John, naming him Elijah, the forerunner of God’s messiah.
But now the tone of his message to those gathered turns more ominous. He compares them to a fickle audience who can’t decide what they want. Or perhaps it’s a divided crowd. Either way, nothing seems to please them. When John came with his message of austere repentance, they complained. When Jesus came welcoming all and proclaiming God’s abundant favor, they dismissed him. To be is to be misunderstood.
What do you want? Jesus seems to ask the crowd. Except he knows they won’t answer. Can’t. Because what they want is to grow, to evolve, to improve and more. And yet at the same time they want to be left alone, untouched and unchanged. Why? Because to change is to lose something, and so to change can feel like dying. And more than anything else the people who listened to Jesus – and the people who listen to you preach Jesus – want desperately to grow but not really to change.
Change, you see, brings the unknown. Change is not certain. Change implies risk and even potential loss. Which is why we often stay in failed jobs and relationships – they may not be much, but at least they’re something and at least we know what to expect.
But here’s the difficult truth about life in Christ. You cannot enter into it and expect to be unchanged. Which means a precondition of receiving Jesus – perhaps the only one! – is to recognize your need for Jesus. Forgiveness, when you think about it, is meaningful only to those who have sinned, grace avails only those who are broken, and the promise of life abundant and eternal is only attractive to those who know they are dying.
I think that’s what Jesus is getting at in the prayer our passage turns to a few verses later. He knows that this kind of message – a message that is good news only to those who can identify their need – will be of little appeal to the self-made man or woman of the first or twenty-first centuries. But it is good news – unbelievably good news – to those who know their brokenness, can admit their need, and who turn to God in Jesus to be known, understood, and accepted.
The recent chapters of Matthew’s Gospel have been dominated by stories portraying Jesus encountering and healing all manner of people – lepers, a centurion’s servant, those who are demon-possessed, a mother taken ill who cannot serve, a women who has bled for years, another who is presumed dead. The one thing all these various and sundry characters have in common is their palpable need. True faith, according to the narrative terms of this story, is simply acknowledging that need and trusting Jesus can respond.
So can we invite our people to do that, dear Partner in Preaching? Can we ask them simply to take stock of their lives, giving thanks for what seems good and right, but also admitting where there is hurt, pain, loneliness, or disappointment? And then can we point them to Jesus, promising them that God knows their struggles, that God has entered into them in Jesus, and that God has promised to heal them and make them whole? It doesn’t happen overnight, of course, sometimes the span of a lifetime is barely enough time to feel God’s healing presence and touch in our lives. But it does happen, and it happens more quickly when we come together again and again to hear the Word of God proclaimed and to receive, touch, and taste the Word of God shared as we gather in Christian fellowship around the sacred meal of bread, wine, grace, and acceptance.
Jesus’ call is clear: you who are content and satisfied will find little of value here. But you who are weary will find rest,
you who feel accused – whether by others or yourself – will find forgiveness,
you who feel abandoned will find fellowship,
you who feel disappointed will find relief,
you who feel hurt will find healing, and
you who feel misunderstood will be known, loved, and accepted for whom you are.
This is the message we are called to preach each and every week, dear Partner. I am grateful for the grace and courage it will take to preach it this Sunday and for the joy it will bring both you and your hearers. Blessings on your life and ministry.
Yours in Christ,
David
So glad “Working Preacher” will continue! I’m switching to the Narrative Lectionary this fall, so they won’t relate directly to my preaching. Will these be “email subscribable”? And also, will your archives stay on the WP site? Lastly, will I be able to search by scripture?
I have used your interactive ideas so often, and your approach to preaching for daily living is very helpful.
Best of luck in your new PA location!
just got it in my in box — great! And answered my other questions by investigating the sites.
Greetings!
I wanted to reach out to you and say “Thank You!” Thank you for sharing your cup of water with all of us! For the past Three years I was an avid reader of the website. Each week I looked forward to your thoughts and comments. Your ministry has helped to shape my own faith formation and the ministry of my community of faith! I thank you for continuing your work in this particular mission field and pray for your continued life of abundance!
Peace,
Pastor Jerry Kulp
Senior Pastor
St. Peter’s Lutheran Church
Bethlehem, PA 18104
Dear David
I am glad you are continuing to share
wisdom about how to preach. I like
your”down to earth approach” to
borrow from other comments. May
God continue to bless your Ministry.
Thank You so much for doing this and thanks to all who stand up every Sunday.
God Bless,
Fr Dave
SO HAPPY this will continue!!!!! Thank you!
I too wanted to stop in and comment that I was glad to read that Dear Working Preacher would continue. I didn’t read it as faithfully as I read ….In the Meantiime, but Dear Working Preacher has gotten me out of some jams when I felt stuck in doing pastoral visits.
Best Wishes to you in your new position at Luther Seminary!
Thank-you so much for continuing these columns — they’ve been very helpful to me in my preaching.
Dear David “Lose”:
I am with you on this famous line in a song of St. Francis of Assisi, a peace prayer.
A feeling of gladness and gratitude came that we will continue to receive your message and preaching.
Jesus Christ’s as a person and his teaching is the MOST misunderstood in our faith. Let us focus in his teaching.
Blessings to you and yours. Perpetua
I am so grateful you are continuing to share your thoughts each week with us as we try to find the “right” words for our sermons; grateful, too, for your prayers and words of encouragement.
I can’t say how happy I am to discover that you are continuing your weekly letters. Though I say it in my own words, your ideas are the inspiration for my Sunday sermons. What a gift they have been! What I appreciate most is your style of making each week more of a dialogue or conversation than a lecture. This is how I prefer to preach.
So bye-bye Miss American Pie… So happy this is not good-bye, but just a change. As you said, inevitable.
David — Thank you for continuing to dialog with those of us who preach weekly…your passion for walking along side and encouraging us (prodding us?) to try new things to help connect the message to our individual lives and our life together as a congregation is a gift. In the meantime…blessings on your faithfulness even in times of change!
YEAH! Since you announced your move I’ve wondered what would happen to Dear Working Preacher as you preach to me and inspire a great many sermons. Thank you for continuing the work.
I’m so grateful. As others have said, your columns have been Word of God for me, which is a rare gift. Thank you for your continuing commitment to the work and blessing of preaching
David,
Thank you so very much! I read your column most every week and cannot even say how much I would have missed it and you!
I will continue to use and support Working Preacher as well, but am more than relieved to know that one of my favorite partners in preaching will continue to be just that. Many blessings!
Just wanted to say thank you for continuing to put your thoughts in print… I read your postings each week and have many times found them to be the place that helped me finally connect the text to the reality of the
day. I am certain that I am not the only “non-communicative” preacher (in that I have never offered a comment on your writing) who has appreciated your insight and support.
Again, thank you.
“. . . by eMail . . .” Ouch! Sounds like a lot of pain over you leaving Luther and the result is divorce. I hope not.
“In the meantime,” we so appreciate your contributions to our ministries. It sounds like you seek us to be colleagues and we instead range from fans to disciples. All I can add to that is, “We could do worse.”
Thank you for all you do.
Yep! Dead on. As the pain of the status quo increases, the incentive to change will increase. We need to keep planting the seeds and let God provide the growing conditions.
I guess this might be called the “Faith” stage.
Hi David,
Dear Working Preacher has been part of my weekly preparation for preaching for years and now even in retirement when I only preach a couple of times a month I read it every week. I am so glad you are continuing this dialog on this site! It not only has given me inspiration for sermons but often has been a source of spiritual food for me. Thank you and blessings on your new ministry.
Please know that I appreciate your letter every week…it helps me tie up my thoughts. God bless you more!
I’ve truly enjoyed your insight and you have helped me free up time to Pastor my flock. So thankful for you!
Dear David,
I like being called Partner, for preaching is a labor of love and while there is work to it, I count it all joy.
A Partner in Christ,
James
San Diego, CA, USA
Dave, I have been inspired by you so many times. I am so glad I will still be able to follow you. Your words have taken on a life of their own and the Holy Spirit is blowing them where He wills.
Last year after our Fall Theological (SWMN ELCA)on the survey they asked if we had any ideas for topics. I told them to invite you and let you talk about anything you wanted to. You will do well in your new endeavor, I know that God will continue to bless you and the works of your hands.And I will continue to read everything you write!!
So glad that you are continuing with ‘Dear working preacher’. Your letters have often been the prompt for a particular sermon. Every blessing in your new role.
Hi, David – I came across WP when I was struggling to find ideas and the commentary as a whole was life-giving. I have, over the last few years, found your letter a source of practical inspiration, and have often adapted your ideas to the context here at the tip of Southern Africa: Cape Town. I’m glad you are continuing to write! Blessings, Mark
I’m so glad to know that your thoughts will continue; I was wondering about that when I heard of your new position – congratulations! I was an intentional interim and was trying to push Bowen Family Systems Theory in every way I could, including a Monday morning Bible group. BFST has become another lens through which I read scripture, and has illuminated it a LOT! So have you, and I would always see if your column was ready by 10AM. Sometimes I would share it without having read it. No matter; the attendees always found it food for thought. I hope they will continue to look for your column – they have left the ELCA, so I am no longer with them. Thank you; thank you; thank you for sharing different ways of thinking!
Thank you for moving your lectionary letter to your blog. I’ve been missing your contributions to the Working Preacher conversation. My mother would call the LTS decision “pooky,” but your response has been gracious to them and generous to your readers.
Oh, David, informed by e-mail?! I am so sorry. I tried leaving comments on the WP site for several weeks and they would not save … hmmmmm.
But thank you for continuing your weekly letters here. I didn’t think anything could be better than “Dear Working Preacher” as a title. I was wrong! Being a Partner in Preaching, even after all these years, has opened a different space in me. I even sat taller as I read the words 🙂
Thank you for your partnership and all your hard work. May the Spirit continue to inspire you and may the peace and grace of God fill you as you settle into your new life and job.
In this age of instant communication we seem to sometimes miss the point of making difficult communication face to face (or at lest via telephone). It is sad that such communication fell to e-mail.
Alas, as a faithful ex-student, and dedicated partner in preaching, I am filled with joy that you continue to be in partnership as God’s Word is preached to the world.
We are better because of who you are in Christ. Blessings to you and your continued work.
By the way – the new title is encouragingly fresh. Thank you for all you do in God’s name.
William Weidenbach Jr
Pastor
St. John’s Lutheran Church
Somonauk, IL
David,
Thanks for continuing your ministry. I deeply appreciate your work!
David
Thank you for the long run at Luther and now as a new “partner” in the task.
I thank God for you every week as I read
Peace to your heart and home
Every week I read your affirmation of the work of preaching with emotion. It is a work of love for me, but as you understand, it is so often unacknowledged. while I always appreciate your insight, and am delighted that you have found a vehicle to continue to share with us, it is most often your encouragement that I look forward to each week. Thank you so much for your partnership with us preachers; I, for one, treasure it.
Understood, accepted, and loved – really all we ever want or need – glad we find it here and glad you are not daunted by these changes,but are keeping on with your writing for preachers and for the rest of us David. Thanks.
Pure gift you are, David. Thank you for your wise, eloquent, accessible, inspiring insights. They are wondrous both for working preachers and for those of us who only occasionally have the opportunity to preach, but who weekly are partners in preparing to worship by opening the Word. Thank you, too, for persisting in your calling. The entire body of Christ is clearly blessed by you.
So glad you will continue your lectionary writing for Sundays here! Thank you!
David, I just want to join the long list of others to say thank you for your work!!! Your insights into the scripture and your style of teaching are refreshing! I have to admit that I have “gleaned” many of your preaching ideas, with great success in my church. selfishly, I pray that you will continue to inspire us. I also pray that this change is a good one for you. Thanks again, and keep up the kingdom work!!!
Working preacher started about the time I headed out for internship. Often, when I couldn’t form coherent thoughts with what was stirring within, I would open Working preacher, and find a letter that seemed to speak exactly to what was trying to form. Thank you for your writings and for your continued writings! Blessings upon your ministry as you follow, leading that other Seminary! I am excited for both of you!
Thank you for continuing this! Of all the things I read each week, your letter from one preacher to another is always the most useful. My congregation is probably tired of hearing about you! Best of luck in your new work. So glad I will still be able to read a letter from you each week.
I’ve read your ‘Dear Working Preacher’ column most weeks for the past 3 years, so I’m delighted that you will continue a weekly column on your blog.
When I first discovered Working Preacher I was “hooked” on your words of encouragement. That soon became the icing on the cake as I receive so many insights and ideas from you. When I met you ( USS Bishop’s Retreat 2014) I was delighted to see that you are every bit as real and engaging as your writings. I thank God for your gifts of affirmation, and insight, and for you.
I discovered ‘Working Preacher’ and your letters when I was going through a dry and uninspired period in my preaching (my congregations might say I’m still going through it!!). The site and your letters opened new doors of insight and approach that got me through that patch and continue to inspire me. However, the most valuable part of it is your benediction and affirmation, which make tangible the virtual and spiritual partnership we share. Each week they make my heart leap and I feel touched by God himself – I feel accepted and loved. I pray that the comments we’ve all left (which will be echoed by many, many more) will touch your heart in the same way. Thank you and most of all thank God for you.
David,
I echo all the above. As others have noted in their own journey, I too have experienced the drought of Spirit and faith and found your letters to Working Preacher the one place that encouraged me to keep on keeping on. Well, that and my paycheck. And that’s a terrible place to be. It seems as though it is where I am still, like I’m Moses with my tent pitched at Pisgah overlooking the land of milk and honey that everyone else has begun to call home. In any event, I was delighted to hear of your professional transition (congratulations), but feared what your departure meant for Working Preacher.
How glad I am to have found you here.
I know that when I leave the pastorate, this will continue to be my daily bread. I may have no idea what I believe anymore, but I believe your thoughtfulness is always worth listening to. So, thank you.
Interesting, isn’t it that our “best” sermons are those we preach to ourselves. Thank you, especially this week, for your insight on change, loss, while being open to the future in Christ.
I so appreciate your partnership with all of us…reminding us of our communal (not lone ranger) task!
Thank you for continuing the letters. They have proved to be encouraging and helpful in my preaching.
Thank you for continuing your weekly letters! I’ve appreciated your insights as I prepare every week to preach. I discover you capture an angle that I have never considered. Blessings on you as you continue this work!
Thank you David, for the inspiration you have brought to my preaching. I am pleased that I can continue to glean from your insights in this blog.
Blessings to you in your new call. Thank you.
Thank you so much David – as a solo pastor I so appreciate your work and ministry – I look forward to entering into a sort of conversation with you each week as I prepare my sermon – I am glad and grateful for your continued sharing and support!
So many have said what I experience… your deep wisdom, joy in the gospel, and profound, vocational support of we who read your words. These are such beautiful gifts! For many of us, they are the way Spirit speaks to us – you are the channel, the mouthpiece, the prophet. And that is a hard role to play. Who supports you?
So let me add my “Amen!” to all the words of appreciation – not to bolster your ego, but to affirm that what you do is of God. It is one way that God chooses to strengthen God’s mysterious bride, the church. And one day you will need to put this great task down. Because it is a burden, I am sure. But I am glad that that day is not today.
Blessings, pard’ner!
I too am so grateful for your great columns! And very pleased your work will continue. You have been invaluable to me each week as I prepare my sermon. I deeply appreciate your insight, your creativity and your faith. Thank you so much, David. Blessings to you!
Hi David: I was relieved and thankful to learn that your weekly insights would continue. I have been much inspired by your scriptural reflections. Charles, Priest in Charge, Merchants Hope Episcopal Church
Dear David:
I am so thankful for your thoughtful reflection on scripture each week. A thorough review of your thoughts are always part of my sermon preparation research and time and time again I am inspired by your work. I am so appreciative of all that you do and the care you take in your research and reflection. You are a true blessing to all of us standing in the pulpit week after week – you’re a real pastor’s pastor – and a brother in Christ. With much appreciation and adoration, Pastor Patty
I echo many of the comments above as a thankful reader of your Dear Working Preacher column. As a part-time lay minister, preaching 1 or 2 times a month for the past 12 years, I was extremely grateful to find the WorkingPreacher.org website soon after it started. My congregation has become familiar with my references to the many contributors there, and I will continue to use its many fine resources. I add my thanks that I will continue to find your preaching help on your own blog. As you have taught us, thank you and thank God for your continued ministry. Best wishes for your new position at LTSP!
St. Paul Lutheran, Chatsworth, IL
I am sorry to hear that the Working Preacher will lose your gifted contributions. I am happy to find your blog and have joyfully subscribed to the email distribution.
Your Working Preacher letter has given me much reflection material as well as good resources for preaching. Thank you for sharing your gift of preaching insight with so many!
Thank you for continuing to share your preaching ministry!
Dear David,
I am blessed and lucky to have been your student while working on my doctorate in preaching these past two years and while I was in seminary at Luther. You are just as insightful and kind in person as you are in your online letters. My heart ached when I read “Dear Working Preacher” and it was not from you. I love Karoline but it is not the same. I am thrilled to be your partner in preaching. You have challenged me to try new ways to reach people with the gospel and encouraged me when I needed it most. You and your family are in my prayers today. Change is hard, even good change. I hope you will visit our cohort in some capacity. Peace, Judy
Dear David,
Thank you for continuing to share your thoughts with your preaching “partners”. For the past year I have grown to appreciate your perspective on each week’s readings. In particular I have heard the Holy Spirit speaking through this week’s comments. Having been part of the conversation you had with a small group at the N.C. Synod office on June 24th I am intrigued by your thoughts on wanting to grow, but yet be unchanged. Thanks for a sparking a clear direction for this week’s message for the congregations I serve. Blessings and thank you
Thank heavens you are still there! I just found you a few months ago and was so pleased that you were thinking a similar direction as I was to whatever the text was that week. I an an Episcopal pastor (and have taught at a couple of seminaries) and my husband (Methodist pastor, more professor) really understand and resent the institutional, narrow-minded folk who probably were unhappy with your success. Thank you for your industry, and being rejected is certainly part of my experience, especially when doing something excelletn.
As I have noted in the past, the church is so focused on Sin/sins that it often feels that’s all it sees me as: separated from God / sinner. Your closing comments are what I believe so many of us need to hear:
Jesus’ call is clear: you who are weary will find rest,
you who feel accused – whether by others or yourself – will find forgiveness,
you who feel abandoned will find fellowship,
you who feel disappointed will find relief,
you who feel hurt will find healing, and
you who feel misunderstood will be known, loved, and accepted for whom you are.
If worship started this way, I could believe the church/God/pastor actually had a sense of what the real issues in my life are and what difference the Word and Sacraments can actually mean to me. Yes, I need forgiveness, but so much more. Bless you!!